Today's Everyday Fashion: Two Versions

Inspired by the catalog photo, I paired these two colors together from my closet. I wore the top outfit before and after the Macy's event on Friday, and the bottom outfit is a winter version for those of you in cold climates. It's also a good illustration of one of my favorite tricks -  creating the same outfit for different seasons as a shortcut. Which version do you prefer?  Would you wear this color combo?

Inspiration photo: Piperlime
Shirt: J.Crew, $45 --> same shirt I'm wearing but slightly different color; I bought mine on clearance
Skirt: c/o LOFT, $30 (similar, longer)
Shoes: Colin Stuart/MJR Sales, $29 (similar)
Earrings: local boutique (similar)
Purse: c/o Karen Millen, $235 (similar, vegan)
Watch: Michael Kors, family gift
Rings: My Stella & Dot website $49 and $69
Bracelets: My Stella & Dot website $59 and $59

Blazer: Express, $25 (similar, similar)
Pants: Gap, $20 (similar, similar --> comes in 6 different inseam lengths!)

1. J.Crew 2. Spence 3. Spence