Today's Everyday Fashion: Switched at Purse

This dress and blazer seem like they were made for each other, but the question is: which purse? My favorite is the middle one, but I'll let you guys be the judge. Purse three is my recent $112 Vince Camuto budget find (also here). In my head this yellow-cognac color was going to be great with my wardrobe but I'm finding it doesn't quite "go." Purses one and two are very different colors but both "go" with these cognac pumps. I have a lot of shoes this color so for purse three not to work is a total bummer! (The tags are still on but I'm not giving up just yet.) Which purse do you like best with this outfit?

Blazer: C. Wonder, $90
Dress: Banana Republic, $30 
Purse: Karen Millen, gift (similar, similar, similar)
Shoes: Nine West c/o (similar, similar, similar)
Necklace: My Stella & Dot
Approx. dates: Shoes and both purses are 2.5 years ago. Blazer is 1 year ago. Dress and necklace are recent.

Limited  /  Limited  /  Century 21  /  Bon-Ton
LOFT  /  Forever 21  /  Gap  /  Limited
Limited  /  Old Navy  /  Limited  /  Tommy Hilfiger